Skip to content

State Farm® Insurance Agent Amanda Procenti

(765) 653-6025
802 E Washington Street
Greencastle, IN 46135-1850

Across from Dairy Castle

Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Amanda Procenti

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5:30pm
9am - 7pm
9am - 5:30pm
9am - 7pm
9am - 5:30pm
9am - 1pm
After Hours by Appointment
Call us 24 hours a day!

Contact me to schedule a virtual meeting


802 E Washington Street
Greencastle, IN 46135-1850


English, Spanish

Hello there and welcome to our website! I want to thank you for visiting my page, and I hope we hear from you soon. Don't hesitate to call us with any questions or to get a quote! We look forward to talking with you.

I wanted to share a bit about myself with you. I live in Roachdale and love that I can provide insurance services to all of Putnam County including Greencastle, Cloverdale, Roachdale, Coatesville, Fillmore, Limedale, Brick Chapel, and Reelsville. I have 4 beautiful children. My two youngest kiddos attend Greencastle schools and they are proud to be Tiger Cubs. We are blessed to become part of this community and I love hosting events with my agency where families from our small communities can get together.

I offer insurance for the whole state of Indiana as well as Illinois. My agency offers car insurance, home insurance, life insurance, farm insurance, and renters insurance. We even offer Pet Insurance to take care of your fur babies! I have 19 years experience helping customers handle insurance claims along with helping customers understand their insurance policies. I personalize insurance plans to make sure the coverage fits the customer's needs. We also have many discounts. You'll be surprised at what great discounts we have! We pride ourselves on provides great customer service to our policyholders.

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products

Banking, Annuities

Skip Infinite Scroll Facebook Feed

Mission: At Amanda Procenti State Farm in Greencastle, our dedication is centered around delivering personalized care and exceptional service to our valued customers. With a genuine commitment to understanding your unique needs, we strive to provide comprehensive insurance options that align with your lifestyle. Our team of experienced professionals is passionate about protecting what matters most to you, and we are here to guide you through the intricacies of insurance with integrity. Together, we are committed to empowering individuals and families by offering reliable insurance coverage and fostering lasting relationships within our community. Ask us about our :

  • Auto Insurance

  • Home Insurance

  • Life Insurance

  • Financial Services and more

Our agency has seven top notch team members ready to service your needs. Not to mention our office mascot, Duke Henry, the office cat. Duke Henry is ready to greet you when you come in. He loves to meet new people and say hello! When you get to our office, there are four rooms inside. The first two rooms you encounter are occupied by Angel, Fayth, and Holly. The next two offices are where you will find Amanda, Dylan, Colby, and Winter. You might also find some of our youngsters hanging out in the lounge after school hours. They like to say hello too! Come by and meet us all. We are ready to help and service you!

Angel Stidd State Farm Agent Team Member

Angel Stidd

Multiple Line Representative

Angel Stidd is a Putnam County resident who graduated from Greencastle High School. When Angel is not in the office, she is usually found spending time with her two children, Daiton and Mercii. She's also usually spotted with a Starbucks in hand. The 3 of them love spending time playing sports with Greencastle Youth leagues, traveling, and being outdoors.

Angel is a brilliant Licensed Multi-Line Producer. Not only does she write Auto, Home, Life and Health Insurance, she has become very skilled at working in Business Line coverage. By providing personalized service to each customer, Angel ensures the coverage is exactly what is needed for the business or individual.

Winter Schultz State Farm Agent Team Member

Winter Schultz

Personal Account Representative

Winter Schultz was born and raised in the mountains of southwest Virginia. She moved to Indiana with her father in 2013 and has lived here ever since. She moved to Putnam County after meeting her now husband. They have one handsome son named Miles. They also have 3 dogs. Frank the black Lab, Kingsley the Maltipom, and Waylon the Catahoula. They also have a cat named Lola. When Winter is not at the office, you can find her boating, fishing, swimming, and spending quality time with her family.

Winter is a licensed insurance producer located in Greencastle, Indiana. Before becoming an insurance producer she worked as a Medical Assistant in the medical field. She became an insurance producer because she wanted to help people learn more about their policies and provide her customers with the reassurance in knowing they have the protection to fit their needs. She believes all policyholders should be aware of their risk exposures. It is her goal to help her customers understand how insurance policies work for them.

Holly Howard State Farm Agent Team Member

Holly Howard

Meet our spunky team member Holly Howard. She has lived in Putnam County her entire life and she graduated from South Putnam High School. Fun fact, while Holly was in high school she was active in choir and placed 1st in a solo singing competition at DePauw University against other high schools. Holly has the most amazing and supportive boyfriend, Damon. She has two kiddos, her son Kaleb and her daughter Raelynn. She also has one fur baby a Pitbull named Knox. She loves spending time with her family outdoors. Some of their favorite things to do are boating, fishing, and riding their dirt bikes and 4-wheelers on their property.

Before Holly became a multi-licensed insurance producer, she was in the medical field. She has always loved helping take care of people when they need her the most. Her goal is to make sure that every customer completely understands their insurance needs, how insurance works, and present them with options to help their families. She wants to make sure our customer’s future is secure and protected in case of the unexpected. Call her today so she can review your insurance options. You are your family's biggest asset, and she will help you cover that asset!

Fayth Whicker State Farm Agent Team Member

Fayth Whicker

Fayth is an Owen Valley High School and Ivy Tech Community College graduate. Fayth has played soccer since she was five years old and continued to play in high school. She was team captain both her junior and senior year, go Patriots! Fayth enjoyed English and History most in school and continues to learn all she can about our ever-evolving world and the history of it. When Fayth is not assisting customers, she can be found with a book and coffee in hand reading the day away. Her favorite type of books are anything fantasy or dystopian related. Fayth’s favorite series is A Court of Thorns and Roses, and she will always be a kid at heart with her next favorite series being Percy Jackson and the Olympians. She is a dog and cat mom to four awesome dogs named Buddy, Lucy, Cane, and Aelin and to two little menaces to society, the felines, named Chandler and Cayla. Fayth enjoys spending time outdoors with her dogs and boyfriend, Cody. They love looking for geodes to add to their ever-growing collection.

Fayth is a multi-licensed insurance producer. Not only can she assist with insuring your car and home, but she also can help with life and health insurance to make sure you are covered in all aspects of your life. Oh, and don’t forget your furry family members too! Fayth can help with pet medical insurance as well! We never know what life is going to throw at us, and making sure we help our customers be protected from every angle we can is Fayth’s goal.

She looks forward to greeting you the next time you swing by the office.

Dylan Phillips State Farm Agent Team Member

Dylan Phillips

Dylan Phillips lives in Owen county and has for 7 years. He grew up in Putnam County and graduated from North Putnam High School. He is happily married to “the most amazing wife ever” and has 2 beautiful daughters. Dylan also has an English bulldog, English mastiff, chocolate lab, Deutsch Drahthaar, and 2 rabbit hunting beagles. When not wearing khakis, he can be found in camo since he is an avid outdoorsman. He’s also the Assistant State Director for a non-profit called Hometown Hero Outdoors. Dylan just got out of the military after 10 years of service where he was an intelligence analyst and a Staff Sergeant.

Dylan is a multi-licensed insurance producer. His goal is to have every customer completely understand their individual insurance needs and coverages. He enjoys working with customers to meet their insurance needs and considers it a good day’s work if every customer he talks to walks away from the conversation with a better understanding of their personal insurance needs.

Colby Green State Farm Agent Team Member

Colby Green

Colby Green is a native of Reelsville and attended South Putnam & Greencastle High School. He has a wonderful wife of 2 years and two lazy dogs Olive and Roka. In his free time, he is usually playing music, woodworking, or leatherworking. You can find his leatherwork displayed in local stores and even catch him playing music at local venues

Before Colby became a licensed insurance producer he worked in hospitality and managed a hotel. He got into insurance because of a desire to help people directly. He gets to do that by educating people on how insurance works and how we can help during their most difficult times. The most rewarding aspect of his career is the meaningful connections he has with the people he meets and knowing that they are better taken care of with our agency than they were before.

Our Agency

Learn more about our agency and the career opportunities with us.
Available Positions
Please Note: This opportunity is about potential employment with an independent contractor agent who solicits applications for State Farm products and services, and does NOT result in employment with any of the State Farm Insurance Companies. The employment selection decision , terms and conditions of employment (such as compensation and benefits) are all determined solely by the independent contractor agent.